Supreme Court Mulls Citizenship Question for Census

The oral arguments the Supreme Court will hear on Tuesday will be more decorous than the gusts of judicial testiness that blew the case up to the nation’s highest tribunal. The case, which raises arcane questions of administrative law but could have widely radiating political and policy consequences, comes from the Enlightenment mentality of the nation’s Founders, and involves this question: Does it matter that a conspicuously unenlightened member of the president’s cabinet lied in sworn testimony about why he made a decision that he arguably has the statutory power to make?Because America’s 18th-century Founders were rational, empirical, inquisitive pursuers of evidence-based improvement, they placed in the Constitution’s second section after the preamble a requirement for a census. And the 14th Amendment stipulates the required actual enumeration, every ten years, of “the whole number” of persons residing in the country. From 1820 (when Congress wanted “foreigners not naturalized” to be counted) through 1950, the census almost always included a citizenship question, and in 2018, Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross decided that the 2020 “short-form” questionnaire, the one that goes to every household, should include one. Ross has testified that he was “responding solely” to a Justice Department request for the question to provide data helpful to enforcement of the Voting Rights Act (VRA) of 1965.

A federal district judge called this Ross rationale “pretextual” because Ross was justifying a decision “already made for other reasons.” This was a polite but still stinging way of saying Ross lied, which he almost certainly did: Justice officials initially rejected Commerce’s request that it ask for a citizenship question, and said such data was unnecessary for VRA enforcement. The district judge said Commerce sought the Justice letter to “launder” the request for the citizenship question “through another agency,” this being just one of “a veritable smorgasbord” of rules violations by Ross and his aides.

Ross also testified that he was “not aware” of any discussions of the citizenship questions between Commerce and the White House. But after 18 states, 15 municipalities, and various immigration advocacy groups sued, he acknowledged meeting early in 2017 with then–presidential adviser Stephen Bannon, an anti-immigration zealot. The district judge also said Ross “materially mischaracterized” — translation: lied about — a conversation with a polling expert in order to obfuscate the expert’s objections to the citizenship question.

Because more information is preferable to less, the citizenship question might seem sensible. However, the question might result in less information because the Census Bureau’s own experts believe that the citizenship question would cause 6.5 million people — almost one in ten households includes one or more noncitizens — to not respond to the questionnaire for fear of law-enforcement consequences. The 6.5 million are approximately as many people as live in Indiana. Of the estimated 24 million noncitizens (about 7 percent of America’s population of almost 329 million), almost eleven million are here illegally.

 Read more at National Review

Current News

Roger Stone sentenced to 3 years

Roger Stone sentenced to 3 years

GOP operative Roger Stone was sentenced to more than three years in prison on Thursday after days of drama ensnaring career prosecutors, the attorney general and the president over...  Read more

Feds Knew 11 Years Ago About Epstein Key Witness Who Could’ve Changed Everything

Feds Knew 11 Years Ago About Epstein Key Witness Who Could’ve Changed Everything

More troubling details have emerged about the previously secret non-prosecution agreement in Florida...  Read more

STEVE SCALISE WINS TWEET OF THE YEAR

STEVE SCALISE WINS TWEET OF THE YEAR

Yes, it seems Ellison completely forgot about Bernie Bro James Hodgkinson...  Read more

Adam Schiff Warns Trump After Roger Stone Sentencing: Pardoning Would Be ‘Breathtaking Act Of Corruption’

Adam Schiff Warns Trump After Roger Stone Sentencing: Pardoning Would Be ‘Breathtaking Act Of Corruption’

Democratic California Rep. Adam Schiff called Trump associate Roger Stone’s sentence...  Read more

Trump stirs pardon speculation with condemnation of DOJ’s Roger Stone treatment

Trump stirs pardon speculation with condemnation of DOJ’s Roger Stone treatment

President Trump's fiery reaction to the Justice Department's sentencing recommendation for Roger Stone is stoking...  Read more

Deep State: Trump Dumps Dozens Of Obama Holdovers In The National Security Council

Deep State: Trump Dumps Dozens Of Obama Holdovers In The National Security Council

President Donald Trump is cleaning house at the National Security Council, scrubbing dozens of Obama administration holdovers in the...  Read more