Court Dismisses Emoluments-Clause Suit against Trump

A federal appeals court handed President Trump a legal victory Wednesday, dismissing a long-running lawsuit alleging that Trump illegally profits from his official position when foreign dignitaries and diplomats stay at his Washington, D.C. hotel.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit unanimously ruled that the attorney generals of Maryland and the District of Columbia lacked the legal standing to bring a suit alleging that Trump violated the emoluments clause of the Constitution by continuing to profit from his hotel’s foreign clientele.

“The District and Maryland’s interest in enforcing the Emoluments Clauses is so attenuated and abstract that their prosecution of this case readily provokes the question of whether this action against the President is an appropriate use of the courts, which were created to resolve real cases and controversies between the parties,” Judge Paul Niemeyer wrote in the 36-page opinion.

Trump immediately celebrated the ruling on Twitter, applying his trademark “witch hunt” label to the lawsuit.

The Democratic plaintiffs, Maryland attorney general Brian Frosh and D.C. attorney general Karl Racine, said they would consider seeking a rehearing before a full panel of the Fourth Circuit and said that the case may eventually reach the Supreme Court. But the pair now face an uphill battle considering Wednesday’s rejection of their argument that Trump’s ownership in the hotel diverts business that would otherwise go to other comparable local establishments.

 Read more at National Review

Current News

Timothy Morrison, Alexander Vindman’s Boss, Reveals Problems They Had With Vindman

Timothy Morrison, Alexander Vindman’s Boss, Reveals Problems They Had With Vindman

Senior NSC official Timothy Morrison, who is the former boss of Lt. Colonel Alexander Vindman, testified on Tuesday that Vindman’s bosses had numerous concerns and problems with him...  Read more

Iran will seek new fighter jets, tanks as 2020 embargo lifts

Iran will seek new fighter jets, tanks as 2020 embargo lifts

Iran will likely buy new advanced fighter jets and tanks next year when a U.N. Security Council arms embargo is scheduled to be lifted...  Read more

Buttigieg in Rivals’ Sights at Debate After Taking Lead in Iowa

Buttigieg in Rivals’ Sights at Debate After Taking Lead in Iowa

The Democratic presidential race’s new pecking order will be on full display tonight...  Read more

FBI investigating possibility of 'criminal enterprise' in Jeffrey Epstein death

FBI investigating possibility of 'criminal enterprise' in Jeffrey Epstein death

FBI investigators probing the death of Jeffrey Epstein are looking into whether a "criminal enterprise" may have played a role...  Read more

Warren once called herself a 'Political Conservative'

Warren once called herself a 'Political Conservative'

Young Elizabeth Warren over lunch one day at Rutgers Law School in Newark, Warren said something surprising...  Read more

Pelosi invites Trump to testify as new witnesses prepare

Pelosi invites Trump to testify as new witnesses prepare

Democratic House Speaker Nancy Pelosi invited President Donald Trump to testify in front of investigators in the House impeachment inquiry...  Read more