Foreign-Policy Retrenchment and the Migrant Crisis

President Trump wants to deter illegal immigrants and asylum seekers from crossing the southern border. He might have more success if he looked at the situation from another angle: Rather than focusing solely on tough measures for unauthorized entry in order to reduce the “pull factor” that draws immigrants to the United States, he might also address the “push factors” that motivate family units and unaccompanied minors from leaving their home countries in the Northern Triangle of Central America.

The appeal of this approach is that the president has far more latitude in foreign affairs than he does in domestic policy, where Congress, the judiciary, and the bureaucracy constrain or thwart his initiatives. Indeed, the only thing preventing Trump from going to the source of the problem — state failure, official corruption, and transnational criminal networks in Honduras, Nicaragua, Guatemala, and El Salvador — is his commitment to a foreign policy of retrenchment. Humanitarian intervention, nation building, entanglements abroad, and foreign aid are unpopular. China, Iran, Venezuela, North Korea, and Russia are trouble enough.

Trump sees foreign aid as leverage, which is why he threatened to stop the flow of money to governments in the Northern Triangle. The problem, Roger Noriega of the American Enterprise Institute pointed out today, is that tax dollars go not to governments but to NGOs and to programs monitored or administered by the U.S. Department of State and USAID. Nor is there much a government can do when a criminal enterprise dominates large parts of its territory. To the extent that central governments in the region do have authority, we need them as allies against the baleful influence of Ortega in Nicaragua, Díaz-Canel in Cuba, and Maduro in Venezuela. Withdrawing ourselves from the region empowers bad actors to create the conditions for mass exodus to the United States.

We’ve deployed economic, political, and military assistance to strengthen democratic governance and reduce civil strife in Latin America before. The most successful case was Plan Colombia, an intensive, expensive, and controversial strategic plan that brought Colombia from desolation to peace and prosperity. But the circumstances that gave us Plan Colombia are no longer present.

Public opinion constrains the president and Congress from an expansive foreign policy, and neither branch of government is interested in persuading the public otherwise. The results are disappointing and sometimes tragic. Why? Because forward defense is not just a military doctrine. It’s also a diplomatic one. When you fail to address challenges abroad, you soon find them knocking on your door.
 

 Read more at National Review

Current News

President Donald Trump orders crackdown on 'visa overstays' in latest push against illegal immigration

President Donald Trump orders crackdown on 'visa overstays' in latest push against illegal immigration

President Donald Trump opened a new flank in his battle against illegal immigration on Monday when he ordered his administration to crack down on "visa overstays" – foreigners who legally enter the country but remain in the U.S. after their visas expire  Read more

U.S. Won't Renew Sanction Exemptions For Countries Buying Iran's Oil

U.S. Won't Renew Sanction Exemptions For Countries Buying Iran's Oil

President Trump will not renew special waivers that have allowed Japan, China, India, Turkey and South Korea to import oil from Iran without running afoul of renewed U.S. sanctions, the White House announced Monday. The waivers are set to expire in early May  Read more

McConnell pledges to be 'Grim Reaper' for progressive policies

McConnell pledges to be 'Grim Reaper' for progressive policies

Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) on Monday vowed to be the "Grim Reaper" for progressive policies if Republicans hold on to the Senate in 2020  Read more

 Trump sues to block House subpoena of financial records

Trump sues to block House subpoena of financial records

Elijah Cummings wants records from accounting firm Mazars USA as part of an investigation into Trump's business empire  Read more

	Elizabeth Warren Wants to Pay Off Your Student Loans with Other People’s Money

Elizabeth Warren Wants to Pay Off Your Student Loans with Other People’s Money

It’s time for bold action to actually fix the debt crisis. Here’s what my new plan would do:  Read more

	Supreme Court Mulls Citizenship Question for Census

Supreme Court Mulls Citizenship Question for Census

This is another case in which Trump administration behavior is provoking plaintiffs to ask the judiciary to police the blurry boundaries of executive discretion  Read more